Diagnostic uncertainty, guilt, mood, and disability in back pain

Danijela Serbic, Tamar Pincus, Chris Fife-Schaw, Helen Dawson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

449 Downloads (Pure)


Objective: In the majority of patients a definitive cause for low back pain (LBP) cannot be established, and many patients report feeling uncertain about their diagnosis, accompanied by guilt. The relationship between diagnostic uncertainty, guilt, mood, and disability is currently unknown. This study tested 3 theoretical models to explore possible pathways between these factors. In Model 1, diagnostic uncertainty was hypothesized to correlate with pain-related guilt, which in turn would positively correlate with depression, anxiety and disability. Two alternative models were tested: (a) a path from depression and anxiety to guilt, from guilt to diagnostic uncertainty, and finally to disability; (b) a model in which depression and anxiety, and independently, diagnostic uncertainty, were associated with guilt, which in turn was associated with disability. Method: Structural equation modeling was employed on data from 413 participants with chronic LBP. Results: All 3 models showed a reasonable-to-good fit with the data, with the 2 alternative models providing marginally better fit indices. Guilt, and especially social guilt, was associated with disability in all 3 models. Diagnostic uncertainty was associated with guilt, but only moderately. Low mood was also associated with guilt. Conclusions: Two newly defined factors, pain related guilt and diagnostic uncertainty, appear to be linked to disability and mood in people with LBP. The causal path of these links cannot be established in this cross sectional study. However, pain-related guilt especially appears to be important, and future research should examine whether interventions directly targeting guilt improve outcomes.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)50-59
Number of pages10
JournalHealth psychology : official journal of the Division of Health Psychology, American Psychological Association
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - Jan 2016

Cite this