TY - JOUR

T1 - Justice Scalia

T2 - Tenured Fox in the Democratic Hen-House?

AU - Marriott, Jane

PY - 2017/5/19

Y1 - 2017/5/19

N2 - This paper examines Justice Scalia’s approach to campaign finance adjudication, in particular his skepticism of legislative motive. Three distinct strands of skepticism are identified: power-grabbing, incumbent-bracing and speech-preventing. As regards democracy Justice Scalia is identified as being caught in definitional dilemma whereby his campaign finance jurisprudence appears to serve a particular vision of democracy, which is, itself, the identifiable creature of his approach to constitutional adjudication. Ultimately, it is argued that, whilst a liberal dose of mistrust of government might well be warranted in cases concerning the devices of democracy, in the task of scrutinising campaign finance regulation and reform, a strong argument emerges for suspicion ofjudicial motives too since there is as much danger to democracy posed by the tenured fox as by the incumbent one.

AB - This paper examines Justice Scalia’s approach to campaign finance adjudication, in particular his skepticism of legislative motive. Three distinct strands of skepticism are identified: power-grabbing, incumbent-bracing and speech-preventing. As regards democracy Justice Scalia is identified as being caught in definitional dilemma whereby his campaign finance jurisprudence appears to serve a particular vision of democracy, which is, itself, the identifiable creature of his approach to constitutional adjudication. Ultimately, it is argued that, whilst a liberal dose of mistrust of government might well be warranted in cases concerning the devices of democracy, in the task of scrutinising campaign finance regulation and reform, a strong argument emerges for suspicion ofjudicial motives too since there is as much danger to democracy posed by the tenured fox as by the incumbent one.

U2 - 10.1515/bjals-2017-0004

DO - 10.1515/bjals-2017-0004

M3 - Article

VL - 6

SP - 41

EP - 57

JO - British Journal of American Legal Studies

JF - British Journal of American Legal Studies

IS - 1

ER -