Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

‘Ancient’ Scottish Music? The Skene Mandore Manuscript: A transcription and re-evaluation: Submitted for the degree of MA by Research in Music

Research output: Thesis › Master's Thesis

Abstract

‘Ancient’ Scottish Music? The Skene Mandore Manuscript: A transcription and re-evaluation

In 1838, William Dauney published Ancient Scottish Melodies: From a Manuscript of the Reign of King James VI, including a partial transcription of the Skene manuscript that now survives at National Library of Scotland, GB-EN Adv.MS.5.2.15. The manuscript is written in French tablature in the first half of the seventeenth century and contains around 120 items of music for mandore, a small type of lute. Its contents are a mixture of English, Continental and Scottish material, the latter including many examples of melodies in Scottish vernacular idiom. Taking the transcription as its starting point, Dauney’s book contains notes on individual items, an essay on modal theory, and a lengthy dissertation on Scottish music history. Dauney’s work was very influential, impacting Scottish music historiography into the late twentieth century. However, neither the manuscript itself, nor Dauney’s volume, has had significant recent scholarly attention.

This thesis re-examines both the Skene manuscript and Dauney’s book, with the aim of providing a fresh exploration of the music’s content and context as well as an evaluation of Dauney’s analysis and its impact. This includes consideration of the non-Scottish music in the manuscript, around 45 per cent of the total. It presents for the first time a complete transcription into mandore tablature and staff notation, alongside cognate details, performance notes, and a spreadsheet containing 26 data points for each item of music, used as a basis for analysis.

Palaeographic research uncovers for the first time the identity of the manuscript’s scribe and owner – previously a matter of speculation – which together with work on cognates suggests significant revision to established dating. Other aspects include contextualisation within the continental mandore and lute repertory, as well as within the surviving Scottish lute corpus. Analytical work includes a full modal analysis and consideration of stylistic elements and relationships, enabling fresh conclusions to be drawn about musical culture and practice in mid-seventeenth-century Scotland. The thesis concludes with a reassessment of Dauney’s volume, looking at his and his collaborators’ overall contribution, and assessing its impact and relevance today.
Original languageEnglish
Awarding Institution
  • Royal Holloway, University of London
Supervisors/Advisors
  • Rose, Stephen, Supervisor
Award date28 Feb 2026
Publication statusUnpublished - 2026

Keywords

  • Early Modern Scottish music
  • Early Modern Scotland
  • Lute and tablature
  • Scottish Lute

Cite this